Stephen A. Smith’s comments on Shohei Ohtani’s ability to speak English are stupid and misleading

Shohei Ohtani may be in the midst of the greatest single-season performance in baseball history.

Obviously, this is not enough for Stephen A. Smith of ESPN-not that anyone should really care. But this popular ESPN artist thinks Ohtani’s use of translators is bad, and believes that his use of translators is actually “harming” the game, which in itself makes no sense.

more: Home run derby brackets, odds, predictions

“But when you talk about spectators, are attracted to the subway, or go to the stadium to see you, I don’t think the first face is helpful…a translator is needed to understand what he is talking about,” Smith said .

In short, Smith’s reasoning was that Otani’s lack of English speaking ability impaired the game because he was unable to connect with the younger generation of baseball fans. Smith said this was a problem because the sport was “in trouble” and needed these. Celebrity.

There are many reasons why these comments are stupid and misleading, and we probably shouldn’t waste time on them. But anyway, let’s break them down:

— Baseball is a sport with a large influx of Latino and Asian players, many of whom are the stars and faces of today’s baseball world. Fernando Tatis Jr., Ronald Acuna Jr., Vladimir Guerrero Jr., to name a few. Although Tatis speaks fluent English, Acuña and Guerrero Jr. still use interpreters to express their opinions in interviews and press conferences.


If an American professional athlete thinks he or she can answer questions and express their ideas in their native language most easily, why not? That is their right-commentators should really have no say in this matter. Japan’s Suzuki Ichiro is one of the greatest baseball stars of his career. He only speaks English with his teammates and chooses to use an interpreter at the press conference. why? Out of respect for language, don’t cause confusion when speaking.

— Some of the best and most famous athletes in the world do not speak English. Have you heard of Messi? He is a big man.

— Using the ability to speak English as a barometer of the popularity of baseball stars is a stupid, short-lived, and failed exercise. Bryce Harper, Mike Trout, Aaron Judge and Muki Bates are the four outstanding stars of Major League Baseball. They all speak English. But they are not the well-known and universal sports stars they should be. That’s not an English problem. This is an MLB problem, and the Alliance is trying to correct this problem. If American, English-speaking players are not getting the treatment they deserve as superstars, how did Ohtani choose to use translation factors here?

— Shohei Ohtani will be the starting pitcher for the 2021 MLB All-Star Game. He will participate in the 2021 MLB All-Star Game. He will participate in the 2021 MLB home run derby. His ability to speak English has nothing to do with his star status in baseball, especially overseas in Japan-if you need to use this as an excuse to discredit or criticize him, then you may need new material.

Therefore, it does not matter whether Otani can speak English. Anyone thinks this is a problem, which is shameful.

Ohtani’s game translation. This is the most important.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *